23.7.2024
Reading time:
7 minutes

Laser lenticule extraction (SMILE, CLEAR, SmartSight)

The latest laser eye surgery procedure: few advantages over Femto-LASIK and Trans-PRK, but additional risks.

Dr. Valery Vinzent Wittwer

Laser lenticule extraction alters the refractive power of the cornea without creating a corneal flap, as is the case with LASIK. The procedure is known by the trade names SMILE, CLEAR or SmartSight and has been in use since 2011. It corrects short-sightedness and astigmatism. Compared with the established procedures Femto-LASIK and Trans-PRK, it offers only minor advantages, but entails additional, procedure-specific risks.

How does laser lenticule extraction work?

A femtosecond laser cuts a thin disc (lenticule) from within the cornea. This disc is then detached from the cornea via a small lateral incision measuring just a few millimetres and removed. This alters the curvature of the cornea and thus its refractive power, in a similar way to Femto-LASIK or Trans-PRK.

__wf_reserved_inherit
1. Lenticule in the cornea
2. Corrected focal point

Who is eligible for this procedure?

  • Short-sightedness ranging from approximately -1 to -8 dioptres
  • Astigmatism up to a limited degree
  • a cornea that is sufficiently thick and regularly shaped

This procedure cannot yet be used to treat long-sightedness on a routine basis. Femto-LASIK or Trans-PRK are the tried-and-tested methods in this regard.

What are the claimed advantages?

  • No flap is created that could slip out of place if the eye is struck.
  • In the first few months, dry eyes occur slightly less frequently than after Femto-LASIK.

Trans-PRK also offers both of these advantages, as it does not involve the creation of a flap either. In terms of visual acuity, laser lenticule extraction has performed less well than modern Femto-LASIK in recent comparative studies (see below).

Is the risk higher than with LASIK and PRK?

Yes, in several respects. With laser lenticule extraction, there are complications that do not occur in this form with Femto-LASIK and Trans-PRK:

  • Difficulty removing the lenticule: in a large study of more than 1,500 procedures, this occurred in just under 2 per cent of eyes.
  • Small tears at the edge of the incision (just under 2 per cent) or a perforation of the overlying corneal layer.
  • Loss of suction during the laser treatment (just under 1 per cent): the procedure then has to be interrupted or repeated at a later date.
  • If fragments of the lenticule remain in the cornea, they can cause irregularities that may permanently impair vision.

Many of these complications depend heavily on the surgeon’s experience.

Will my vision be just as good afterwards as it is after LASIK?

Recent comparative studies involving the latest generation of equipment suggest otherwise. Following laser lenticule extraction, visual acuity is, on average, poorer than after modern, individually calculated Femto-LASIK, and it takes longer for patients to see clearly.

In a study in which 60 patients had one eye treated with Femto-LASIK and the other with laser lenticule extraction, 98 per cent of the LASIK eyes achieved very high visual acuity after three months, compared with only 82 per cent of the eyes treated with lenticule extraction. The target correction was precisely achieved in all LASIK eyes, but only in around three out of four eyes following lenticule extraction.

What if a subsequent correction is needed?

A follow-up correction is more complex after laser lenticule extraction than after Femto-LASIK or Trans-PRK. The procedure itself cannot be repeated on the same eye. Follow-up correction is carried out either by means of a surface treatment (PRK), which involves a longer and more uncomfortable healing process, or by subsequently converting the existing incision into a LASIK flap.

What other risks are there?

  • Under- or overcorrection, so that weak glasses may still be needed
  • Halos and starbursts around light sources, particularly at night and during the first few weeks
  • dry eyes
  • Inflammation or, very rarely, infection in the area of the incision
  • very rarely, weakening and bulging of the cornea (keratectasia), as with all laser eye procedures

Eye Zurich does not offer laser lenticule extraction. The reason is the balance of benefit and risk: the advantages over Femto-LASIK and Trans-PRK are small, the additional risks are not.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is laser lenticule extraction the most advanced technique?

It is the most recent of the established laser eye surgery procedures. However, newer does not necessarily mean better: Femto-LASIK and Trans-PRK have been tried and tested for decades, with millions of procedures carried out and very good long-term results.

Will I be able to take part in contact sports again after the procedure?

Yes. However, if you do contact sports or your job carries a risk of blows to the eye, Trans-PRK is also a good choice: it does not require a flap and has no additional procedure-specific risks.

Which procedure is right for me?

This depends on your vision problem, the thickness and shape of your cornea, your job and your leisure activities. Ask for the pros and cons of the different procedures to be explained to you in a consultation.

Further information on EyePedia

Sources

This article is no substitute for a consultation with a doctor. Please consult an ophthalmologist to determine which procedure is suitable for your eyes.

Dr. Valéry Vinzent Wittwer
Autor
Dr. Valéry Vinzent Wittwer
FMH Ophthalmologie, speziell Ophthalmochirurgie
Mehr über den Autor und Termin vereinbaren

You might also be interested in this

Eye laser

RefractiveQuest – questionnaire before your consultation

Before your consultation on laser eye surgery, implantable lenses or lens exchange: a short questionnaire about your eyes, your daily life and your wishes. About 10 minutes, nothing is stored.
Eye laser

Phakic intraocolular lens

The abbreviation PIOL stands for phakic intraocular lens and means that a type of contact lens is placed in front of the natural lens in the eye